Saturday, September 8, 2007

Mixed metaphors and messages...

An article in the NYT describes the growing concern over economic conditions, and all of the candidates' immediate desire to assign blame on you-know-who and to proclaim how they'd do better. It's obviously an irresistible way, I suppose, to score points. Much as I think the Bush administration has acted childishly and incompetently in almost every area, however, I find it awfully hard to give them any responsibility for the property market, or the irresponsible lending practices that pumped the bubble for so long. That's happened before and it will happen again. (They can be attacked much more reasonably on their policies that have led to exploding inequality.)

But I'm still not convinced that anyone can really predict and manage an economy on the basis of anything more scientific than the reading of tea leaves. As far as I can tell, economics, especially the "macroeconomics" of entire economies, is still very far from being a real science. (I wonder if any readers out there -- perhaps, some economist -- can point me to any data showing that economists can predict the movements of economies with anything like the accuracy one routinely finds in the rest of science? I'd be very interested to see such evidence.) This post from the Leiter Reports, although three years old, gives an interesting (legal philosopher's) perspective on economics as a science, and it's one I find myself largely agreeing with. Economics has been so committed to rational behavior, to proving mathematical theorems (which makes it look scientific), and even worse, perhaps, to the notion that all systems can be understood by supposing they are in some equilibrium, that it's tied one or both arms behind its back in its efforts really to understand economic phenomena.

Remarkably, these theoretical addictions still persist. An economist told me that it's still very hard to publish in some of the "best" economics journals if one does not assume that economic agents are fully rational. This is a problem in the sociology of the economics discipline. But it's changing, of course, as it would have to if economics is going to grow into something more intellectually sound. One promising development, for example, is a great body of work in computational economics, in which researchers aim to make plausible assumptions about human behavior -- based hopefully on empirical evidence -- and then use computational models to explore outcomes in large systems of interacting agents.

For now, we're still largely stuck with metaphors, and mixed ones at that. Take this gem from the NYT article on how the Fed manages the money supply:

Typically, the Fed raises interest rates to ward off inflation when the economy is growing fast and in danger of overheating, and lowers rates when the economy is slackening.


Apparently, the economy is sometimes an automobile at risk of overheating, and at other times, a sailing vessel stranded as its sails slacken in weak winds. Take two metaphors and call me in the morning. But can macroeconomics go much beyond such metaphors? I'd like to be convinced, but I'm not yet.

228 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 228 of 228
Shariful said...

Alabama Fresh Air Huntsville Locksmith provides quick 24/7 locksmith services for home lockouts, lock change, car lockouts and more for auto, commercial and home in the Huntsville and Madison, AL area. madison locksmith

jokerindo99 said...

jokerindo99

areaslot said...

tunggu apa lagi segera nikmati permainan terbaik dari areaslot

WORLD NEWS said...

we are blog provided us with valuable information to work with. Each & every tips of your post are awesome.We have added a new tip for you. Visit the site and see Clipping path service Thanks a lot for sharing. Keep blogging

Image Retouching said...

Absolutely perfect presentation.We have added a new tip for you. Visit the site and seeClipping path service Thanks a lot for sharing. Keep blogging

WORLD NEWS said...

It is very helpful Great site for these post and i am seeing the most of contents have useful for my Carrier successful. Any information are commands like to share him. again thanks for your kindness Clipping path service Thanks a lot for sharing.

WORLD NEWS said...

Your Blog is very very interested. But my product a Essential path really have many business planning! check my site forClipping path service Thanks a lot for sharing.

Socially Best said...

Perfect for good post and point. I'm not sure that this is actually the best place to ask, but do you have any ideology to hire some professional writers? Thanks in advance.
Buy Best Jeans Online in UK

sahil rana said...

Exactly what i was looking for. Can you write on USB Drive Data Recovery Chandigarh as well.

vishal bytes said...

Thanks for taking the time to discuss and share this with us, I for one feel strongly about it and really enjoyed learning more about this topic. Please share some more useful info on Server Data Recovrery Chandigah also. I can see that you possess a degree of expertise on this subject.

Mayur sharma said...

This is really an amazing article. Your article is really good. Please share something on Raid Data Recovery Chandigarh as your article has always good content with informative information.

Mayur sharma said...

This is really an amazing article. Your article is really good. Please share something on Server Data Recovery as your article has always good content with informative information.

BISE Federal Board Matric Supplementary Result said...

ncredible goodѕ from уou, man.
I've comprehend your stuff past to and you are simply incredibly extraordinary. I truly like what you've obtained heгe, truly likе what you're expressing and the manner by which you state it. You make it engaging you despite everything deal with to keep it reasonable. I can hardly wait to peruse undeniably more from yοu. Thіs is actually a great websіte.

Multan board Intermediate supplementary 2020 said...

I contemplated financial matters in school and discovered that companies carried on as judicious benefit boosting substances. It has been instructive to work in a genuine organization, watch the dynamic procedure and perceive how unique it is from the scholarly model. I don't have any exhaustive hypothesis of corporate conduct, however three things ring a bell.

Bahawalpur Board 9th Class Result said...

BISE Bahawalpur tests are commonly held in the long stretch of March and April. Understudies get their move number slips from the board before the tests. Test date sheet contains data about the assessment community and tests timings.
BISE Bahawalpur Board ninth class result 2020 is generally declared following 2 to 3 months of the tests. We transfer the outcomes on our site following the outcome announcement

Danny said...

Well said. Here starting a Locksmith Pembroke Pines online services. Any type of key-locks problem can be solved. You will get the professional workers for sure.

mobilelegendshack diamond said...

mobile legends hack apk

mobilelegendshack diamond

Mobile legends

mobilelegendshack diamond said...

mobile legends hack apk

mobilelegendshack diamond

Mobile legends

SarkariNaukriHona Team said...

listoutnow.com applauding job !

Danny said...

You should install an alarm system to peacefully perform your yoga. Because there can be a burglary situation. To install an alarm or lock system you should hire a professional Locksmith Miramar so that they can install it precisely.

homescapes cheats said...

homescapes cheats
Homescpaes Cheats

homescapes cheats said...

homescapes cheats
Homescpaes Cheats

homescapes cheats said...

homescapes cheats
Homescpaes Cheats

Diana Ayla said...

First of all i am saying that i like your post very much.I am really impressed by the way in which you presented the content and also the structure of the post
karma build

Samia Akter said...

I totally agree with you. And I was very pleased with that. Awesome features and facts.. :) stigma

All Bio said...

Bạn đang không biết lô khung 2 ngày có những dạng phổ biến nào? Câu trả lời dành cho bạn sẽ được chia sẻ trong thông tin của bài viết dưới đây. 188xoso

France Lotto Results said...

UK49s is something that is like a jackpot without any guess involved in it like prize bonds. While betting is something that involves playing skills and tricks to win a lottery.

This game is played in many countries but it is most popular in the UK49s and South Africa. It is named after the number of balls involved in the game. There are 49 balls, each labeled by a number from 1 to 49, thus the name of game 49s!

Angel Number 555 said...

The Angel Number 555 indicates that your vibrational frequency is about to change. This change is something that you will be able to notice. You’ll start noticing opportunities and people that you hadn’t before. They have a different “hum” to them and now resonate with your own frequency. Other people start to feel more static than anything else.

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 228 of 228   Newer› Newest»