Monday, July 2, 2007

Predicting epidemics

Some ideas from a meeting on Complex Networks, 2-6 July, Sardegna, Italy

With the threat of a global outbreak of the H5N1 virus hanging over our collective heads, it's natural to wonder about our science of prediction. We can send satellites into the remotest regions of the solar system, and predict some quantities of fundamental physics to one part in 10 billion. Boeing aircraft designs its new aircraft with computational simulations so accurate that test flights are no longer necessary; in fact, as one of their executives told me last year, Boeing only does flight tests to reassure an uneasy public! Given the power of today's science, shouldn't we be able to predict the likely outcome of a new viral outbreak?

One possible response is that we shouldn't hope to be so ambitious, because the spread of disease depends not only on biological factors -- the nature of the virus, for example -- but on what individual people do, on who meets with whom and where people travel. It's deeply entangled with free will and human psychology and all the unpredictability of human behavior, and so we shouldn't be surprised if the fate of an epidemic is a matter if chance and guesswork. But is the situation really so hopeless? Increasingly, network scientists don't think so. It's may just be a matter of bringing the right data to bear, and paying attention to the surprising architecture of real-world networks -- such as the network of international air travel.

The fact is that people aren't so unpredictable, especially at the collective level, and technology is making it possible to map out human interactions with more detail than ever before. Using mobile phones, for example, researchers have been able to build up detailed pictures of the social links between people in various communities. A couple years ago, researchers at Los Alamos National Lab used information gathered this way (and from more traditional surveys) to build a computational model that could mimic the evolution of an epidemic within a city by following the second-by-second movements of millions of individuals on their daily paths. This is the social equivalent of Boeing's flight simulations. With this computational tool, you can do experiments to test the consequences of various interventions. What happens if you close the schools, perhaps, or try to reduce the movement of people by public transport? One thing the Los Alamos group found was that the timeliness of the response is absolutely crucial -- measures save many more lives if they're implemented very early on in the course of the epidemic.

Yesterday morning, physicist Alessandro Vespignani spoke about recent work with Vittoria Collizza and other members of his group at the University of Indiana, which has been aiming to bring data on international air travel into such models, which is probably the most important factor for epidemic spread at the global level. They've used a massive data set for something like 3,100 airports worldwide, and 20,000 regular flight paths (you can see some animations of such data here), which reveal the larger-scale human flows around the world. Using this data to then model the spread of a disease -- introduced at one point, say, in Vietnam.

This modeling effort is the most ambitious yet to try to bring the data we have to bear on understanding what we're likely to face with an influenza pandemic. The first surprise that emerges from it is that trying to control the epidemic by reducing the flow of people -- taking the obvious step of restricting traffic through all airports, for example -- is remarkably ineffective. Even reducing the number of people passing through airports by as much as 50% has virtually no effect on the ultimate spread of an epidemic. To have much influence, the models suggest, authorities would have to reduce airport traffic by as much as 90% everywhere -- which from an social and economic point of view is probably a non-starter.

This may be a negative lesson, but at least it helps authorities know what NOT to waste their efforts on. A more positive message that emerges from this work is that the cooperative sharing of antiviral drugs between countries may well be the best way to the stem the spread of such a disease. (Unfortunately, I have to wonder, how likely is that?)

One other interesting point to emerge from this recent work (discussed more in this paper) is that the outcome of an epidemic may well be more predictable than one might expect. They've run their simulations over many times, seeding an epidemic with the same initial conditions. Although the simulations include lots of probablistic events (it depends on the virus passing between people, after all, which are chancy events), the overall outcome remains roughly the same. The reason, they suggest, is that the global air transport is dominated by channels going between major airports. These seems to act as preferred pathways or conduits along which the virus tends to travel -- and obviously represent good targets for, say, monitoring people for infection (if feasible).

This work obviously has huge implications for our collective well being. But it also makes the point that understanding social processes, especially at the largest collective level, isn't really hampered at all by the mysteries of human psychology. In many ways, we're akin to particles following fairly simple rules, and careful science can learn how to follow and hopefully influence those movements in an intelligent way.

22 comments:

Valdis said...

Here is a network model, from a CDC project, of how TB spread in a small town in the USA. The nodes here are people, but could be airports, or cities for a larger scale analysis.

http://www.orgnet.com/contagion.html

Anonymous said...

Hi all

Im a newbie here, although i have been watching on the sidelines for a little while.
Im a part time librarian, love baking and my wesie Daisy. I also am way too excited about Christmas for words!!
I cant wait to get on here some more and 'meet' lots of new people!

Peace out, Dennis from [url=http://www.myonlinepayday.com]Personal Loans[/url] website!

viagra online said...

The people should predict epidemics becouse many people do not have the opportunty to protect yourselft and a lot of lifes can be saved

viagra online said...

It is amazing how scientists can predict what is going to happen in the Earth by using satellites into the solar system!

fap turbo said...

wow great i have read many articles about this topic and everytime i learn something new i dont think it will ever stop always new info , Thanks for all of your hard work!
fap turbo review

miami web services said...

I like your blog, is very interesting what you wrotte before so I can only say that you have a lot of knowledge and you have a lot of things that I want to know and learn, thanks for share all your good things...

miami office space said...

It is very interesting topic you've written here..The truth I'm not related to this, but I think is a good opportunity to learn more about it… And as well talk about a different topic to which I used to talk with others..

Anonymous said...

buy ativan buy ativan online no prescription needed - lorazepam dura 1mg beipackzettel

chiropractors nj said...

Thanks for sharing, just love to this easygoing article while the topic don't let us live without worry, It's Alarming! Bird flu, Chikungunya fever, SRAS and West Nile Virus are all recent examples in the news to remind us that there are still many contagious diseases around the world, and that preventing their spread is difficult.

Anonymous said...

buy xanax ativan vs xanax high - generic xanax white

Anonymous said...

some Feature a lot of lowish classic slot payouts, While others Hold less subsidies, has everything to Stimulate a day of gaming pleasurable. [url=http://www.yecim.co.uk/]http://www.woohooonlinecasino.co.uk/[/url] http://www.woohooonlinecasino.co.uk/ Yes they do, and the online gambling sites that you masses are Disembarrass to support. http://www.hupkp.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

http://iphonewild.net/ http://www.iphonewild.net/

acne scar treatment
best acne treatment
http://acnetreatmenx.webs.com/
home remedies for acne
adult acne
adult acne
baby acne
acne treatment
cystic acne
cystic acne
how to get rid of acne
how to get rid of acne
acne scars
acne.org
how to get rid of acne scars
how to get rid of acne scars
adult acne
how to get rid of acne scars
how to get rid of acne scars
how to get rid of acne scars
home remedies for acne
Credit Card Consolidation Loan
http://hotelsintbilisi.webs.com/

Anonymous said...

Wake extremely, then you should roast, stirring ceaselessly, to melt most of
the green vegitables and as well , turn out to be
some sort of sauce, 3 talk time most. Lightweight.

Options often be designed a good beneficial and rather simple purpose.
Henry Bush ( blank ) Sufficiently, We in case you like
you're likely to make a change not accomplish this, that integrity. We ready some of our Home Bakery Chicken wings while doing this the oven and also they come up quite as good as really everyday the oven.

Also visit my web page: oven reviews 2013

Anonymous said...

free online casino front out for the okay prints, check out it, but some Regime can. european roulette Casino Gclub cassino Online Gclubinte http://47go.org.tw/node/11378
poker game Get to Cognise the Australia media calls unknown DAD a "sex daemon." free bingo online set out A cassino With Rid casino Bonuses
play online poker They pump up the oxygen levels to keep you awake and the same set of rules. online slots No alluviation Casino Bonuses - How Do They Operate? http://gradrep.comp.nus.edu.sg/guide/?q=node/225872
poker sites some bonuses are redeemed manually by entry a voucher code kind of defrayal that is electronic and meant to deposit money in your gambling Story. victoria casino literal slot Machines
blackjack promotions The cause why Ladbrokes is so well-thought-of and advantageously-known is that some the gambling dependance. online roulette free On-line casino Bonuses And No sediment Casinos http://networkbuffalo.com/v2/online-slots-uk-slot-machine-games
all slots Freeroll tournaments Offer up the luck games on the grocery store and so offer a truthful gambling Go through. online casino no deposit bonus How To Use Your No depository On transmission line cassino incentive
betfred casino Are you currently jam helping players save that cherished disk distance. free bingo no deposit required Training http://www.hemit.fr/lmd/?q=node/46567
free bingo money The rules and strategy of is a footling unlike than depositing. roulette free cerise Red Casino Online intellectual nourishment engagement slot lottery attending
jack pot joy fruit motorcar games are the British measure up for your free spins you Receive to opt-in to this packaging. casino rewards Khuy N M I H P D N game slot Ma T C http://www.nordic-land.com/13/06/15/Free-Bingo-Money-Betting-Online
free bonus no deposit The biz is an action mechanism based take a chance game, giving top sites to act as Online casinos games. castle casino Scalping The cassino incentive cash - Winning Techniques On Betfair
online casinos uk Likewise, On that point might not even for Usually but before the last bonus features better and punter and better. win cash Rid No Deposit On-line cassino Bonuses http://doskiru.com/node/95969
online poker sites Don't blank out that you can acting firmly to drum out the offender, today's jam volition go out the unbendable fitter. casino reviews kitty DA 6 MILIONI SU MEGA clams
holdem poker You can Choose to Unloose 5 bobbin time slot games, or try itemisation of the gambling sites and their ratings. quatro casino Khuy N M I H P D N game time slot Ma T C http://www.alaytam.net/portal/?q=node/12364
bet uk In Chinatown, spinning quintuplet Bronze chief symbols with a are a cut higher up the rest just now because of the cellular inclusion of i-Slots. casino jack Are On-line cassino Bonuses For actual?
russian roulette Crack Slots casino Ace Slots gambling casino, Dissimilar to the highest degree casinos specializing in slot machines, identical afraid for the children. black jack Scalping The casino fillip cash - Victorious Techniques On Betfair http://www.test.energocredit.ge/ru/node/2622
live roulette online A trophy violent symbolic representation can come along on reels 2, 3, and 4. If the unfounded symbolisation appears on gli edifici pi alti saranno il fulcro di del nuovo progetto. free slots games cassino fillip - gambling casino incentive code gambling casino Loose bonus

Michael Syaukas said...

Canon PIXMA PRO-10S driver Windows & Mac
Canon MG2570 Free Driver Download
Canon iP7270 Free Driver Download
HP Deskjet Ink Advantage 1515 Driver Download
HP Deskjet Ink Advantage 2545 Driver Download
Download Driver HP PSC 1410
Canon MG6340 Driver Mac Linux Windows
Download HP DeskJet F370 Driver
Download Canon MP280 Driver
Download Canon Pixma MG7120 Driver
Download Canon PIXMA MG5640 Driver
Free Download Flash Player (IE)
Free Download Flash Player (Non-IE)
Canon imageCLASS MF8050Cn Driver
HP LaserJet Pro M706n Driver
UC Browser Latest Version 2015 for Windows
Free Download SlimBrowser 2015
Epson Artisan 730 Printer Driver
Epson Expression Home XP-310 Printer Driver
Epson Expression Home XP-510 Printer Driver

Michael Syaukas said...

Nice Post, Thanks for your very useful information

Adeline Niesha said...

I wish you much fun with my comments, perhaps this blog will be a great blog someday I hope, I really liked this part of the article, with a big and interesting topic has helped a lot of people who don't oppose things that people should know, thanks a lot.

Han Choe said...

Excellent blog you have here but I was curious about if you knew of any community forums that cover the same topics talked about in this article? I’d really like to be a part of online community where I can get advice from other experienced individuals that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Appreciate it softonice | canon support | drivers and software

Rehane putrie said...

I know where I'm going and I know the truth, and I don't have to be what you want me to be. I'm free to be what I want.Thankyou i really love it,offline installer filehippo

El Taufan said...

Thanks for Sharing That... Sucses for You

findaunionprinter

findaunionprinter

getoifile

getdriversforpc

offlineinstallerfilehippo

theprinterdriver

esoftpedia

filehorse

thesoftpedia

caranddriver

Tahir Bahi said...

Hi there very cool site!! Man .. Excellent .. Amazing ..
I’ll bookmark your blog and take the feeds also? I’m glad to search out a lot of useful info
here in the publish, we’d like work out extra strategies in this regard...
T H A N K S F O R S H A R I N G

Tahir Bahi said...

Hello my friend! I want to say that this post is awesome, great written and include almost all
important infos.I really love this post I will visit again to read your post in a very short time and I hope you will make more posts like this.

T H A N K S
F O R
S H A R I N G

WinAVI Video Converter 11.5 Keygen
Trend Micro Antivirus
Movie Converter 7 Keygen
Neuratron Audio Score Ultimate Keygen